The complete record of every published pick: wins, losses, and closing line value, graded against real final scores.
Losing picks stay on the page. A record with the misses removed is not a record, and closing line value is shown because it measures whether a pick beat the market, not just whether it won.
The difference between the price you took and the price the market closed at. It matters because the closing line is the market's most accurate estimate, so consistently beating it is evidence of a real edge — much sooner than win rate alone can show.
Because a record with the misses removed is not a record. Variance means good bets lose often, and the only way to judge a process is to see all of it.
Against real final scores and box scores after the game settles, using the line that was published at the time of the pick.